Sell Your O’Reilly Auto Parts Property

Considering selling your O’Reilly Auto Parts property? NNN Realty specializes in net lease investment sales across the country. Learn how buyers evaluate O’Reilly leases, why lease structure and the timing of rent increases matter, and what to expect throughout the selling process.

Request a Property Valuation Get Recent Comparable Sales

The O’Reilly Auto Parts Market at a Glance

Short Answer

The value of an O’Reilly Auto Parts property depends on the remaining lease term, the rent and where you sit in its increase schedule, and whether the lease is NN or NNN. Many O’Reilly leases leave the roof or structure with the landlord, so the exact repair language can move your price as much as the credit does. Buyers also look at the store’s market position and recent comparable sales when deciding what to pay.

Typical cap rate
5.5% to 7%
Typical sale price
$1.25M to $2M
Typical term left at sale
5 to 10 years
Typical lease type
NN

Approximate ranges from NNN Realty’s tracking of O’Reilly Auto Parts listings and reported sales, with data as of October 6, 2026. They are a starting point, not an appraisal or a quote of current pricing: your property’s value depends on its lease, location and condition.

How to Sell Your O’Reilly Auto Parts Property

Selling an O’Reilly Auto Parts property requires a precise reading of the lease, especially who pays for what, and an understanding of how buyers price O’Reilly’s investment grade credit. Our process helps owners set realistic pricing, reach qualified investors, and move the transaction from valuation to closing.

  1. Property Review & Valuation

    We review the lease in detail: remaining term, renewal options, the rent schedule and the date of the next increase, and the landlord’s obligations for the roof, structure, parking lot and HVAC. We pair that with the store’s location, trade area and competitive position, and with recent O’Reilly sales, to recommend an asking price grounded in current market conditions.

  2. Market Positioning & Buyer Targeting

    We present the property with professional photography, drone imagery where helpful, and an offering memorandum that spells out the lease structure and increase timing so buyers do not have to guess. We then target buyers who regularly acquire O’Reilly properties, including 1031 exchange investors, private investors and institutional net lease buyers, backed by nationwide marketing exposure.

  3. Offers, Buyer Qualification & Negotiations

    When offers arrive, we weigh price alongside each buyer’s track record, financing or proof of funds, due diligence requests, and ability to close. Buyers sometimes adjust offers for landlord responsibilities on NN leases, so we address those items early. We help negotiate a non-binding Letter of Intent (LOI) setting out the key terms before moving to a formal Purchase and Sale Agreement (PSA).

  4. Due Diligence & Closing

    After the Purchase and Sale Agreement is executed, the buyer generally begins a negotiated due diligence period, often around 30–45 days. The buyer reviews the lease, title, survey and environmental reports, and on an NN lease commonly orders a roof and property condition inspection. During this time the buyer may be able to terminate and recover the earnest money deposit.

    We manage document delivery, site visits, the tenant estoppel from O’Reilly, and coordination with the buyer, attorneys, title company and lender. If the purchase agreement provides for it, the deposit becomes nonrefundable when due diligence expires, subject to contractual exceptions. Closing usually occurs within roughly 15–30 days after that, though timelines vary by transaction.

What Is My O’Reilly Auto Parts Property Worth?

The value of an O’Reilly Auto Parts property is primarily set by its net operating income (NOI) and the capitalization rate (cap rate) investors will accept. Not all O’Reilly properties trade at the same cap rate. Remaining term, NN versus NNN responsibilities, and how close the next rent increase is can noticeably change what a buyer will pay.

How Cap Rates Affect Your Property’s Value

A cap rate represents the relationship between a property’s annual net operating income and its purchase price. Generally, a lower cap rate results in a higher property value, while a higher cap rate results in a lower value.

Example: $100,000 annual NOI at 6.25% cap rate = approximately $1,600,000 estimated property value.

Property Value = Annual NOI ÷ Cap Rate

Cap rate calculator

6.25%

Estimated property value$1,600,000

Illustrative calculation only. Actual sale prices depend on property characteristics and market conditions.

Factors That Influence O’Reilly Auto Parts Property Values

  • Remaining Lease Term

    A newer lease with many years left draws the most buyer interest and the strongest pricing. As the primary term nears its end, buyers look for signs that the store will renew.

  • Lease Structure & Repair Obligations

    O’Reilly leases range from NN to NNN, and on many of them the landlord still pays for the roof or structure. Clear repair language and a well-maintained building reduce the discount buyers apply.

  • Rent Increases & Timing

    O’Reilly leases commonly increase rent every five years, so the years right after an increase can feel flat to buyers. Selling ahead of a scheduled increase can capture value buyers are willing to pay for.

  • Store Strength in Its Market

    Trade area demographics, nearby competition, and the store’s sales trend help buyers judge the odds of renewal. Any available performance information can support a stronger price.

  • Tenant Credit & Lease Guarantee

    O’Reilly is rated investment grade, and the tenant is commonly O’Reilly Automotive Stores, Inc. with a guarantee from the parent company. Confirm the tenant entity and guarantee in your lease rather than assuming them.

O’Reilly Auto Parts as a Tenant

O’Reilly Auto Parts serves both do-it-yourself customers and professional repair shops, and the company operates its stores itself rather than franchising them. Leases are commonly signed by O’Reilly Automotive Stores, Inc., often with a guarantee from O’Reilly Automotive, Inc. These details can differ from store to store, so confirm the tenant entity and any guarantee from your lease documents.

As of June 30, 2026, O’Reilly operated 6,695 stores across 48 U.S. states, Puerto Rico, Mexico and Canada. It opened 110 net new stores in the first half of 2026, is targeting 225–235 net new stores for the year, and reported comparable store sales growth of 6.0% in the second quarter. That steady growth helps buyers feel comfortable about renewals, though they still study each store’s lease structure and term.

Parent company
O’Reilly Automotive, Inc. (Nasdaq: ORLY)
Stores
6,695 as of June 30, 2026
Credit rating
BBB from S&P Global Ratings and Baa1 from Moody’s, both with stable outlooks (as listed for its August 2026 notes offering)
Common lease terms
Often a 15-year initial term on new stores with renewal options and rent increases every five years; many leases are NN. Confirm roof and structure duties in your lease.
Typical building
About 7,000 square feet on 0.7 to 1.1 acres

Company facts checked October 20, 2026. Sources:

What Is Your O’Reilly Auto Parts Property Worth?

Considering selling your O’Reilly Auto Parts property? NNN Realty can help you understand its current market value by reviewing your lease structure and increase schedule, recent comparable sales, and the buyers active in O’Reilly properties today.

Whether you’re ready to sell or still deciding on timing, we can provide a clear, informed assessment of your investment.

Request a Property Valuation

NNN Realty is not affiliated with O'Reilly Automotive, Inc.. Market ranges are approximate, based on listings and sales tracked through October 6, 2026, and the calculator is illustrative. Nothing here is tax, legal or investment advice.